The performance of mutual funds is often assessed using CAGR (Compound Annual Growth Rate) or XIRR (Extended Internal Rate of Return). However, these measures overlook the critical dimension of risk. Evaluating risk-adjusted returns offers a more comprehensive perspective, balancing potential gains with volatility. Here, we analyze the performance of mutual fund categories across capitalization funds, thematic funds, hybrid allocation funds, active debt funds, and alternate funds over a 5-year period ending December 2024.
Capitalization Funds: A Balanced Act
Large-cap funds surprisingly outperformed on risk-adjusted returns, owing to their lower volatility. Small-cap funds, despite high returns, ranked lower due to sharp volatility. Multi-cap funds emerged as a top choice, offering a strong balance between returns and risk.
Highlights:
- Large-Cap Funds: Risk-adjusted returns of 1.9433, driven by low risk (range: 8.46).
- Small-Cap Funds: Highest average return (31.55%), but lowest risk-adjusted return (1.3119) due to high volatility.
- Multi-Cap Funds: Delivered a solid performance with 1.8907 risk-adjusted returns, outpacing flexi-caps.
Thematic Funds: Consistency Matters
Thematic funds showcased positive average returns across all 11 categories. FMCG funds ranked highest on risk-adjusted returns due to their stability, while technology funds led on CAGR returns but with increased volatility.
Highlights:
- FMCG Funds: Risk-adjusted returns of 8.0460, supported by minimal range of 1.74%.
- Technology Funds: Best average return at 30.38%, compensating for its volatility with a respectable risk-adjusted score of 4.3215.
- ELSS (Tax Savings) Funds: Despite solid returns, they ranked low on risk-adjusted metrics due to high volatility.
Hybrid Allocation Funds: Rule-Based Approaches Win
Hybrid funds showed that formula-based allocation outperformed discretionary strategies. Balanced allocation funds led due to their structured approach, while dynamic bond funds struggled due to elevated risk.
Highlights:
- Balanced Allocation Funds: Top performer with risk-adjusted returns of 3.3713, backed by low volatility.
- Aggressive Allocation Funds: Strong average return (16.93%), but lower risk-adjusted score (1.0174) due to high range (16.64%).
Active Debt Funds: Stability at the Forefront
In active debt funds, tenure or duration had limited influence on performance. Funds with lower volatility, like 10-year government bonds and money market funds, delivered superior risk-adjusted returns.
Highlights:
- 10-Year Government Bonds: Top performer with 3.3353 risk-adjusted returns and a narrow range (1.70).
- Dynamic Bond Funds: High average return (6.22%), but poor risk-adjusted returns (0.5325) due to elevated volatility.
Alternate Funds: Precious Metals Dominate
Among alternate funds, precious metals funds, primarily gold, stood out for their strong risk-adjusted performance. These funds combined stability and consistent returns to outperform arbitrage and liquid funds.
Highlights:
- Precious Metals Funds: Exceptional risk-adjusted returns of 15.1932, with a minimal range (0.88).
- Arbitrage Funds: Steady performance with a score of 2.0268, offering stability in uncertain markets.
Key Insights and Takeaways
1. Low Volatility Outshines High Returns: Funds with limited volatility and controlled risk management often deliver superior risk-adjusted returns.
2. Rule-Based Strategies Excel: Categories like balanced allocation funds demonstrate the effectiveness of minimizing fund manager discretion.
3. Thematic and Capitalization Insights: FMCG and multi-cap funds proved that steady, consistent strategies can outperform volatile sectors like small-cap or infrastructure funds.
4. Debt Fund Trends: Stability in government bonds and money market funds highlights the importance of controlling risk in fixed-income portfolios.
5. Gold’s Unique Position: Precious metals funds continue to shine, combining low volatility with high risk-adjusted returns.
Conclusion
The 5-year risk-adjusted returns analysis underscores the importance of balancing returns with risk. As mutual funds aim to optimize performance, the focus should shift from merely chasing returns to effectively managing volatility. Categories that embrace low volatility, rule-based strategies, and limited discretion are likely to remain investor favorites, delivering not just returns but sustainable performance in the long run.
For more details and structured learning, please explore our risk management courses.
